So Much For Germany's Green Economy (Welcome, Dirty Black Coal)

by on

This is the second in a two-part series. The first part can be found here.

The IHS research quoted on 24/7WallStreet.com reckons that high energy prices will cost the German economy 40,000 jobs in the chemicals sector by 2030 under one pricing scenario, while machinery and motor vehicle manufacturing could lose 85,000 and 87,000 jobs. Not only do solar and wind raise costs, they also reduce stability. The rising and setting of the sun can be predicted to seconds, but the intensity of light and KWhrs of power are less reliable. Wind is even worse, leaving generating capacity idle during peak demand one day but contributing the next. Under such circumstances, most countries ensure a base load of supply by maintaining low-cost always-on power sources such as nuclear or coal.

Free! Download this month’s MMI® Report on price trends for the global precious metals market. 

The drive to renewables in Germany should run counter to maintaining a high dependency on coal, but (and some may say hypocritically) Germany has five new coal-fired power plants with a combined capacity of around 4 GW going through their “first fire” trials this summer. Although generators are at pains to stress how very efficient these new plants are, much of Germany’s coal-fired power production uses lignite, the dirtiest form of coal. Overall, Germany’s coal-fired power plants (including lignite) contributed more than 50% to the nation’s electricity demand in the first half of this year, with more coal-fired capacity likely to be commissioned before the first nuclear plant is taken out of service in 2015, Platts tells us.

But if lowering total emissions is the objective of the government’s potentially ruinous investment in renewables, their decision in May 2011 to immediately shut down eight of the country’s 17 nuclear reactors, with the remainder to close before 2022, is bizarre. The decision was taken, so we are told, in response to the Fukushima tsunami, perhaps on the basis that Germany’s reactors could experience the same catastrophe. Before the shutdown of the eight reactors is taken into account, Germany relies on nuclear power for 23% of its electricity generating capacity and 46% of its base-load electricity production. Coal will partially replace that nuclear base load– but at the cost of CO2 emissions, which can presumably only be countered by further renewable investment. According to another Platts article, power generation from natural gas fired plants actually decreased this year to under 10%.

So what does the future hold for Germany’s industrial model? Just as the US is benefiting from an era of low power costs, a promise that has already encouraged significant investment in the petrochemicals, steel, and fertilizers, Germany will be entering an era of ever higher power costs. Ironically, these are power costs that the largest, most energy-intensive industries may continue to avoid, but other parts of the manufacturing sector, dominated by the German Mittlestand, small and medium businesses, plus retail customers, will bear the brunt. This will simply shift costs down the supply chain and directly impact Germany’s ability to compete in the long term. Yes, it will drive innovation and investment as firms fight to survive, but as that innovation leaks out to competitors, high energy costs will become the albatross around the neck of Germany’s ancient mariner. With such a power policy raising costs and reducing stability of power delivery, the country will face a major challenge in the years to come to maintain its position as number two exporter to the world.

FREE Download: The Monthly MMI® Report – price trends for the renewables market.

Comments (2)

  1. Uncle B says:

    Will Germany rise above the crass Capitalist evaluation here, find Wind, Tidal, Wave and Geothermal expansions for base loads, less wasteful energy practices than others, even develop better technologies, by force of energy conservation to compensate for differences, even find newer, less energy intense systems, methologies, technologies, approaches. Article here assumes the Status Quo as the pat answer, takes it for an imaginary base line and projects the past onto the future, by American measuring sticks, leaves no room for even the advent of newer electric transportation, sees no chance for electric bullet trains, neglects the Thorium thrust of other nations for safer, cleaner, nuclear, even foregoes the science that brought mankind this far. We are in Global Economic Shift as these pat, opinionated, close-minded, notions are presented. even the Tesla car, all aluminum, all electric shows up the Old Boys Club, V-8 gasoline engine mentality here. Coming down the tubes at you, at computer speeds, ideas as radical as the conversions from steam to internal combustion, rail to jet flight, D.C. electrics to A.C. electrics, Bessemer to induction furnace steel, a new world, where shoveling on the coal is no longer the economically appropriate technology and, even as the computer directed robot lines turn out labour free product, and a more educated populace designs ever better systems, hydraulics and electo-servos replace brawn, even humble China re-engineers the American spawned Thorium reactors with LFTR technologies that promise near waste free nuclear power without the plutonium spectre, and pebble bed gas reactors already trying Thorium in their pellets, a world of change smashing your Old Boys Club notions.
    Be advised: an intelligentisa pool in Asia, now larger than any the world has ever seen, deeper than the American poole by a magnitude, and fully computer equioed as never befre in mans history, tackle problems never faced in the old Europe and America of the coal shuttle and Bessimer furnace. All Asia faces huge coal emmissions problems, and work dilligently toward a solution or even solutions to all fossil fuel contingencies. Expect miracles unforetold from this mass of intelligent research beyond your coal shovel experience, and into a new future for all mankind.

    1. Lisa Reisman says:

      Well now there’s an opinion for you! LAR

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.